MOOMOO

PLENAR

Part 02 ·

In December the sun crosses
the whole room.
In June it stops
at the window.

House with a pergola: a MOOMOO project
House with a pergola, a MOOMOO projectvisualisation

A south-facing window gets more sun in December than in June, and that is precisely when the patch of light crosses the whole room. In summer it lights only a strip by the glass. That is one of several things that came out when we counted the sun in our houses minute by minute.

The second part of the series on the plan study. We calculated the model of the sun's position for Łódź, latitude 51.76 degrees, for the 21st day of each month, at five-minute steps. A window “sees” the sun when it is more than 5 degrees above the horizon and within 85 degrees of the perpendicular to the glass.

One caveat straight away: this is a cloudless sky with nothing in the way. No trees, no neighbours, no overhang. The result is the maximum possible for a given orientation, not what will happen on a particular Tuesday.

The path of the sun over Łódź

Before the windows, one drawing that explains all the rest. This is the same path the sun takes over the house on three days of the year. Each dot is a full hour.

The path of the sun across the sky: 21 June, 21 March and 21 December

21 June 21 March 21 December

eastsouth-eastsouthsouth-westwest

The vertical axis is the altitude of the sun above the horizon, from zero to 62 degrees. In June the sun rises in the north-east and at noon stands 61 degrees above the horizon; in December barely 15.

How much sun a window gets, depending on which way it faces

Hours of direct sun on a window, 21 June
east7.4 h
south8.5 h
west7.4 h
north5.0 h

Summer time. A north window gets direct sun only from April to August, early in the morning and late in the evening, when the sun rises and sets behind the line of the façade.

The same window, 21 December
east2.7 h
south6.1 h
west2.7 h
northnone

In December the day in Łódź lasts about eight hours. A south window gets six of them.

Hours of sun on a window through the year

east south west north

JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec

Vertical axis from zero to eleven hours. Calculated with the same model as in the study, in five-minute steps; rounding may differ from the report by a few minutes.

South has the most even year: from six to eleven hours, with its maximum not in June but in March and September. In June the sun stands so high, and rises so far to the north-east, that the south elevation gets less of it than in spring.

How deep into a room the sun goes

With a window running from floor level to 2.8 metres, the patch of sun on the floor at solar noon reaches this far.

Section through a room: how far the patch of sun reaches at noon

21 June, 1.5 m 21 March, 3.5 m 21 December, 10.6 m

The window runs from the floor to 2.8 m, on the left. The drawing is to one scale horizontally and vertically.

A typical room in our houses is 3.4–4.4 m deep. In winter the sun crosses it entirely and reaches further; in summer it lights only a strip by the window.

This inverts the intuition most people arrive with. Winter sun, low above the horizon, reaches deepest and warms the room exactly when that is wanted. Summer sun, high overhead, stops at the glass and can be cut off with a horizontal overhang or a pergola without taking anything away from winter.

Breakfast and dinner

Instead of counting hours across the day, we counted two particular moments: breakfast between 7 and 8 in the morning, and dinner between 6 and 7 in the evening.

Minutes of sun on a window during the breakfast hour, east-facing window

07:00–08:00

0Jan 46Feb 60Mar 60Apr 60May 60Jun 60Jul 60Aug 60Sep 60Oct 15Nov 0Dec

Windows facing north-east, east and south-east have a full hour of sun from March to October. In December and January there is no sun at that time in any orientation.

Minutes of sun on a window during the dinner hour, west-facing window

18:00–19:00

0Jan 0Feb 0Mar 60Apr 60May 60Jun 60Jul 60Aug 21Sep 0Oct 0Nov 0Dec

From October to March it is already dark at six in the evening whatever the orientation. Surprisingly, a north window has 30–60 minutes of sun at that time from April to August, and a south window practically none.

From this follows a simple consequence for kitchens and dining rooms. A kitchen set up for breakfast and a kitchen set up for dinner are two different kitchens on two different sides of the house, and only one of them can be had. For seven months of the year dinner happens by artificial light anyway.

Our houses, by their real orientation

The model applied to the azimuths read off the site layouts. Each row is the elevation the living zone opens onto.

HouseAzimuth of the elevationMarchJuneDecember
House 239 m²106°, east-south-east06:25–12:2005:10–13:0508:40–12:25
House 344 m²110°, east-south-east06:25–12:3505:10–13:1008:40–12:40
House 408 m²125°, south-east06:25–13:2505:10–13:4508:40–13:45
House 456 m²162°, south-south-east06:25–15:5506:55–15:3508:40–14:40
House 268 m²188°, south07:00–17:1509:10–17:3508:40–14:40
House 276 m²250°, west-south-west11:05–17:1512:15–20:1510:40–14:40

Living zones open to the east-south-east have sun from morning to noon: breakfast in the sun, afternoon in shade. The last in the table works the other way round, from noon to evening.

Sun on the bed

For the house whose full geometry we hold as a model, we calculated something that is not usually calculated: whether a ray of sun falls on the mattress. Every fifteen minutes, for the outline of each bed from the furniture layer, with the mattress at 55 cm. We count the hours in which at least a tenth of the bed's surface is in sun.

The hours in which sun lies on the bed, 21 June
master bedroom6.5 h
child's room, west5.0 h
child's room, west-south2.5 h

House 456 m², floor-to-ceiling windows, orientation from the site layout, with no external shading and no curtains.

The same, 21 December
master bedroom2.5 h
child's room, westnone
child's room, west-south2.5 h

The master bed has between 2.75 and 6.75 hours of sun a day all year round. In summer that means warming the mattress and the bedding in exactly the hours before sleep; in winter, pleasant light in the afternoon. On the children's beds the June sun appears from half past three, that is at afternoon-nap time, and in one of the rooms stays until half past eight.

How much heat the sun brings in

Daylighting in our houses is many times above the legal requirement and above good practice. Polish law requires windows to be at least 12.5 per cent of the floor area; good practice talks about 20–25 per cent. In our living zones it comes out between 70 and 100 per cent. So the risk is the opposite of the usual one: not a shortage of light but overheating and glare.

Solar heat in a bedroom on a cloudless July day, per m² of glass
east- or west-facing window1.9 kWh
south-facing window1.3 kWh
north-facing window0.4 kWh

Unshaded glass, solar factor g ≈ 0.5, direct radiation only.

A bedroom with a floor-level window of about eight square metres of glass facing west gets some 15 kWh of heat a day in summer, much of it in the afternoon, just before sleep. That is two and a half times more than with a three-metre window. External shading cuts it roughly in half.

For comparison: every ten square metres of glass facing west is about 2 kW of heat at peak, that is as much as a large electric heater. The courtyard glazing in the largest of our houses is 62 square metres. Facing west it would give about 23 kW at peak and 117 kWh a day. It faces south-south-east, so it gives about 14 kW and 87 kWh, and the peak falls at noon rather than in the evening.

In practice this is an argument for a southern orientation where the glazing is large. Not because it lets in less sun, but because high summer sun from the south can be stopped with a horizontal overhang, and low western sun can be stopped by almost nothing.

The shadow of the house on its own garden

A house does not only catch the sun; it also takes it away. For a building eight metres high, the shadow at solar noon looks like this.

Section: the shadow of an 8 m high house at solar noon

June, 4.3 m March and September, 10.1 m December, 30.3 m

The house is on the left, the shadow falls to the right, to the north. The drawing is to one scale.

A garden on the north side of the house is in shade at noon to a depth of 25–30 m from November to January, and to about 15 m in October and February.

We place gardens and terraces on the south or west side of the house, so that the shadow of the building falls on the drive and the street side. It is a decision taken when the massing is being placed, while it still costs nothing.

There is many times more light than the law requires

So far we have counted sun, that is the ray that enters a room. Daylight is something else: the whole brightness of the sky, including on an overcast day. Here our houses do very well.

CriterionReference valueIn our houses
Floor-level windows, legal requirementmin. 12.5 per centmet everywhere
Floor-level windows, good practice20–25 per centchild's room about 22 per cent, living zones 70–100
Room depth against head heightno more than 2 to 2.5 timesrooms 3.4–5.1 m against a limit of 5.6–7.5; met
Deepest living zoneas above7.3–7.5 m with a 3.0 m head height, within the standard
Daylight factor, EN 17037about 3 per cent for 300 luxall living rooms and bedrooms above the threshold, most of them two to three times over

The factor is calculated with the BRE formula for the two houses with native models. The result is an upper estimate: it does not account for overhangs, pergolas, trees or neighbouring buildings.

With windows that have a sill instead of running to the floor, the factors would drop by roughly half. A floor-level window keeps deep rooms within the standard, and that is why we use it.

We set out the joinery in a study on the plan together with the windows, not add it to finished walls. Furniture in the band next to the glass takes away light that the plan does not show.

Light in the evening

Finally, something connected to the plan only indirectly, but which came out along the way. A consensus published in PLOS Biology in 2022 recommends no more than 10 lux of melanopic EDI in the evening, in the three hours before sleep, and no more than 1 lux during sleep.

How much ordinary light fits inside that limit depends on colour temperature. At 2700 K it is about 21 lux at eye level, at 1800 K about 67. High ceilings, from 3 to 3.6 metres, and large open spaces encourage lighting from above, which passes that limit without difficulty. Evening light is better designed low: floor lamps, strips near the floor, points beside the seating.

When exactly is it daylight

Three times of day, in which three different rooms are used, and three entirely different answers to the question of whether it is light then.

  • Working in the study, eight to four. Daylight all year round, even in November and December seven and a half hours out of eight. What decides the quality of the light is therefore the depth of the room and the orientation, not the season.
  • Dinner in the kitchen, five to eight. Daylight only from April to August. From October to February the whole meal happens by artificial light.
  • Morning, six to eight. Light from March to August. In December and January bedrooms and kitchens wake up in the dark, for some four months of the year.

That sets the priorities differently from the way they are usually set. A study window works all year and is worth designing for the quality of its light. A dining-room window does not work in the evening at all for half the year, so what decides that room is the artificial lighting described above.

What follows from this in design

The orientation of the living zone is a decision about the time of day, not about the amount of light. East gives breakfast in the sun and shade in the afternoon. West gives the opposite, at the cost of overheating. South gives the most even year and is the only orientation where solar shading works simply.

With large areas of glass, external shading is not an addition but part of the design. Two kilowatts for every ten square metres of glass is a number to settle during the concept, because after that what is left is air conditioning.

A bed has an orientation of its own. Sun on the mattress for six hours in June is a decision worth taking deliberately rather than discovering in the first summer.

Sources. Standard EN 17037 and the room-depth rules. Brown T.M. et al. (2022), Recommendations for daytime, evening, and nighttime indoor light exposure, PLOS Biology 20(3): e3001571. Baniassadi et al. (Harvard, 2023), sleep and bedroom temperature. House data: MOOMOO detached house plan study, final edition, October 2026, parts 10, 15, 16, 19, 21 and 23.

Licence. The figures and charts in this part are released under CC BY 4.0. They may be quoted, adapted and used commercially, crediting MOOMOO Architects as the source. Photographs and visualisations are not covered by the licence.

The whole study in one file

A hundred and thirty-five pages, twenty houses and apartments, fourteen parts and a hundred and eighteen drawings. Everything this series was built from, in full. The file is in Polish; the drawings and tables read without it, and an English edition is in preparation.

135pages 20houses 14parts 118drawings

The data controller is MOOMOO GROUP s.c. Jakub Majewski, Łukasz Pastuszka, ul. Polskiej Organizacji Wojskowej 25/14, 90-248 Łódź, Poland. We will use the address to send the report and, with your consent, further materials. Details in the privacy policy.

Prefer to look first? The whole series is readable here, part by part, without signing up.

Compiled by: Łukasz Pastuszkaarchitect, co-founder, MOOMOO Architects

We will run the numbers
for your plot.

Let’s talk about your project